Educational Approaches

There are some basic approaches to education, explained below. They can be used with fidelity, for instance, you can teach using only pure Project-Based or Academic-Focused curricula. You also can pick out parts you like from several, and combine them. The parts can also be integrated with a purchased curriculum, to enrich it or customize it to better suit your child and his or her interests.

Each has its pros and cons, and it may take trial and error to learn which ones are best for your child and program. Some of them have little to no direct instruction and others lean heavily on direct instruction. Research has shown that direct instruction can help children learn content faster, within a play or project-based program and it is easy to add to any of the systems that usually do not rely upon direct instruction. The important thing is to offer experiential activities that reinforce the direct instruction lesson concepts, letting your child practice and play with the ideas and skills.

When I worked with families as a teacher, a common problem homeschool parents had was in getting their children to do the work. The kids would refuse or fight them, and not be motivated to do the work. As a teacher, I learned to create lessons that engaged the kids. If they were engaged, they were motivated to do the work. If a lesson didn’t engage them, I could hold out the reward of a session of play or a project or game they loved, that they could do after finishing their dreaded worksheet or studies. If the work was too difficult because the child could not yet understand the content, waiting a few weeks or months to reintroduce it, can do wonders. If your child has a chronic bad attitude about working on schoolwork, the curriculum could be a bad fit. Find something they look forward to doing each day, where there’s no battles to get them to do it. There are many products, companies, books, methods, and you can even go your own way and design something that is tailor made for your children.

The other thing that helped me was using “Love and Logic” methods of discipline with them. My students related well to this and it cut down on the resistance and behavior problems. Kids are expected to own their lives with “Love and Logic” and to be their own bosses, follow rules, maintain healthy boundaries. The key to success with “Love and Logic” is to have a playful tone, to show empathy, to not show anger or disappointment, and to ensure there are logical consequences, positive and negative, for every action. Have rules, high expectations, and follow through every time, no exceptions.

Playful Learning

https://www.naeyc.org/resources/pubs/yc/summer2022/power-playful-learning

This article explains the importance of play in the early childhood learning environment. It should form the base for learning, not be a treat or added onto a workbook-based format. Play is how young children learn. They are concrete-thinkers and learn with hands-on experiences. When they can move things, assemble parts, use art, build things, and use all their senses, they learn faster and easier. When school is set up for play, they will love school and work hard. Children naturally want to learn to read and write, they want to know math, and are driven to do so. When these are integrated into play, it is a natural format for children to learn.

Direct Instruction

Direct instruction is also an important part. Teaching facts or content helps children make sense of things and prevents misunderstandings. It. should be kept to about one minute per age of child, to start, and should include more questions than answers. Questions will help you know what the child is thinking and then any misunderstanding of the content can be corrected.
Play can then contain activities that reinforce the lesson that was just presented. The activities will give the child opportunities to interact with the information and solidify ideas. During play, the teacher can sit near the child and ask thoughtful, open-ended questions, to engage the child and extend his or her thinking.

Key Considerations

  • Find a philosophy and approach that you connect with and think you and your child will enjoy.
  • Research curricula and materials that will help you teach within your philosophy and preferred approach, while meeting the needs and interests of your child.

Curriculum Approaches Overview

1

Montessori Method

https://www.britannica.com/topic/Montessori-schoolshttps

  • Self-directed learning
  • Unrestricted movement
  • Free-choice activities
  • Hands-on learning
  • Peer-to-Peer learning
  • Learning materials are available in the marketplace
  • Teacher is an advisor or guide, not instructor
  • Assessments are through portfolios and observations, not tests

2

Reggio Emilia

https://www.naeyc.org/resources/pubs/yc/nov2015/emergent-curriculum

  • Self-directed learning
  • Environment is important
  • Focus on relationships
  • “Provocations” provided to spur curiosity and creativity
  • Teacher is a guide for learning
  • Taps into natural curiosity and creativity of children
  • Art is an integral part
  • Open-ended projects and explorations
  • Few purchased materials
  • Emphasis on connecting with nature
  • Assessments are through portfolios and observations, not tests

3

Project-Based Learning (PBL)

www.pblworks.org


  • Real-world projects
  • Work on projects over an extended length of time
  • Builds problem-solving skills
  • Taps into ceativity
  • Content knowledge is strengthened
  • Teachers act as advisors
  • Highly engaging
  • The work is personally meaningful for students
  • Usually involves making presentations, speeches, demonstrations

4

Play-Based Learning

https://www.gse.harvard.edu/ideas/usable-knowledge/23/05/embracing-learning-through-play
  • Builds social skills
  • Strengthens problem-solving skills
  • Creativity and imagination are used
  • Meaningful activities
  • Integrates science, math, literacy, and social studies naturally and easily
  • Builds stronger oral language skills, the foundation for literacy and social-emotional skills
  • Taps into child’s interests
  • Teacher acts as guide or facilitor
  • Makes learning joyful
  • Child sets the pace
  • Good way to teach collaboration and negotiation skills
  • Highly engaging
  • Developmentally appropriate through age 8
  • Can be combined with direct instruction and short periods of time for seat work to increase academic rigor

5

Academic-Focused Learning

  • Structured
  • Traditional or Classical types
  • Seatwork
  • Measurable outcomes through tests
  • Teacher-Led
  • Can be quite rigorous
  • Relies on memorization
  • Can cause anxiety
  • Developmentally inappropriate in PreK and Kindergarten
  • More difficult for students with ADHD, Autism, or other special need
  • Can squelch creativity
  • Oral language skills may not develop as well as through play
  • May not engage the student, harder to maintain focus and enthusiasm
  • Many homeschool programs are based in these theories, are heavy on screen use or worksheets and most people are unaware that there is any other way; it is the usual default curriculum for many homeschoolers
  • Academic practices can be woven into any of the activity-focused types of education
  • An academically focused curriculum can be used as a basis for the content knowledge, in short bursts, with play or activities being used as the bulk of the day

Philosophies of Learning